Air of Mystery or Open Book?
mystery
noun
mys·tery ˈmi-st(ə-)rē
1
a: something not understood or beyond understanding : enigma
The mystery of his disappearance has never been solved.
2
: profound, inexplicable, or secretive quality or character
the mystery of her smile
the mysteries and beauties of nature
Dear Friend,
Do you ever struggle with how much to share with people?
My 2025 was jam-packed with travels and experiences, which naturally brought me in contact with a lot of new folks. Maybe it’s my lack of sticking to the “normal” path of socializing through the institutions of the world, but connection is often confusing to me.
For example, the other week, I went to an event where I ended up talking to a girl the same age as me. We hit it off, but since we were both waiting for the event to start, we mostly made small talk. When she asked the innocent question “Are you a student?” I managed to stutter a strange “no” in a hesitant voice. She looked at me confused, and though I contemplated expanding, I held myself back.
The conversation fizzled awkwardly at that, and thankfully, the start of the event saved me from further embarrassment. However, this interaction got me thinking: how deep does one go?
Here is a stranger, asking me a completely normal question to which the answer should be pretty straightforward. But I hesitated because of the amount of baggage and backstory is associated with the question.
Would it be more or less awkward to start expanding on the fact that I’ve never finished high school due to a debilitating chronic illness or let the conversation die the painful death it was fated?
Do I trauma-dump with the whole truth or risk seeming cold with my straightforward answer? Do I embrace my air of mystery or risk being “too much”?
What level of intimacy do I allow myself to build with a stranger, and how vulnerable should I get?
If my hope is to build a lasting connection, I’d say honesty is the best policy. But this is not a question of honesty. My short and curt answer is just as true as my long explanation would be. That’s exactly why I struggle with this.

When it comes down to it, I know there is no right way. If I share all the nitty-gritty and my story scares someone away, so be it. If I don’t feel like exposing myself and my counterpart doesn’t maintain interest, that’s okay too.
The beauty of being human is that you have different types of dynamics and relationships with each person you meet. I have accepted that to some, I may be boring, cringe, or annoying, but to others, I may be inspiring, wonderful, or even cool.
Contrary to what I believed for a long time, I do not have to be perfect, and it’s okay not to know.
For now, I’m leaning more towards disclosure and leaving the hiding behind. Let’s see if that desire can translate into reality.
So, if you have any advice on how to balance how much to share with strangers, please feel free to do so in the comments. No matter what, the key lies in owning your story with as little shame as possible. I’ll be practicing honoring myself in each moment, never forcing exposure, yet not getting comfortable hiding away from it either. Will you join me?
Don’t forget,
I love you.
